How Are Interest Rates Impacting Commercial Real Estate in Maine?

Data Clues: Linking Cap Rates & Interest Rates

In the commercial real estate (CRE) sector, the interplay between capitalization (cap) rates and interest rates is fundamental, influencing valuations, investment strategies, and market activities. Initially, the rise in interest rates that began in early 2022 did not immediately affect cap rates. This delay can likely be attributed to borrowers locking in lower rates for a period following the initial interest rate hikes.

However, the landscape began to shift throughout 2023 as the volume of sales for leased properties declined. This reduction in sales volume is primarily related to the diminished investment viability due to the increased cost of capital. Consequently, the cap rate comparables derived from recent sales became less reflective of the current market conditions a scenario that prompted us appraisers to rely more heavily on calculated cap rates, incorporating the current interest rates into their assessments.

Despite these adjustments, data collected shows only small signs of increasing cap rates across most markets. Specifically, in certain sectors, and in some markets across all sectors, cap rates have been slow to rise. The multi-family market, for instance, maintained consistently low cap rates throughout much of 2023 only showing increases toward the end of the year.

Demand Varies

Markets comprising older, existing stock are becoming increasingly perceived as riskier investments due to potential future repair or renovation needs. Contrarily, the industrial sector has demonstrated steadily strong investor appeal due to very low vacancy risk and reliable appreciation. This high demand has kept cap rates generally low in many markets for this asset class.

The office and retail sectors present mixed trends influenced by market-specific demand generators as well as the creditworthiness of the tenant and durability of the resulting revenue stream. In short, when a tenant is strong and lease terms meet investor criteria in terms of length of term and ROI, the property sector is of somewhat decreased importance in the market.

The Importance of Balance

In conclusion, it is evident through data and anecdotal evidence from commercial real estate brokers and market stakeholders Statewide that rising interest rates have indeed influenced cap rates across most markets and property sectors. Nevertheless, the pace and extent of this impact vary significantly by sector and location.

The nuanced relationship between cap rates and interest rates highlights the intricate balance investors must navigate. While higher interest rates elevate cap rates, reducing property values due to increased borrowing costs, the complexity is further heightened by factors such as market conditions, investor sentiment, and risk premiums. Understanding this interplay is crucial for understanding the movement in commercial real estate markets.

---

2024 CMA Market Surveys

Subscribe to the CMA Newsletter